EP005: Difference between revisions

Showdown in Pewter City

EP005   ニビジムのたたかい！ Nibi Gym Battle!

First broadcast Japan April 29, 1997 United States September 14, 1998

English themes Opening Pokémon Theme Ending

Japanese themes Opening めざせポケモンマスター Ending ひゃくごじゅういち

Credits Animation Team Ota Screenplay 武上純希 Junki Takegami Storyboard 井硲清高 Kiyotaka Itani Assistant director 井硲清高 Kiyotaka Itani Animation director 松原徳弘 Norihiro Matsubara Additional credits

Screenshots on Filb.de

Showdown in Pewter City (Japanese: ニビジムのたたかい！ Nibi Gym Battle!) is the fifth episode of the Pokémon anime. It was first broadcast in Japan on April 29, 1997, and in the United States on September 14, 1998.

Spoiler warning: this article may contain major plot or ending details.

Blurb

Jessie, James, and Meowth dig a trap for our heroes, but they end up falling into it themselves!

Ash and Misty arrive at Pewter City and meet a curious fellow named Flint, who notices that Pikachu is tired and shows them the way to the Pokémon Center.

At the Pokémon Center, Ash reads a poster promoting the Pokémon League Regional Championships—to compete, you have to beat gym leaders from various towns and win their badges. Ash challenges the Pewter City Gym Leader, Brock, but even a healed Pikachu has no chance against Brock's Rock-type Pokémon. Later, Flint shows Ash a surprising side of Brock—when he's not battling and raising Pokémon, he has to take care of his ten brothers and sisters.

Will this news affect Ash's desire to battle Brock again for the Rock Badge? Who is this Flint guy, and why does he insist on helping Ash train Pikachu for the rematch? And will Team Rocket ever climb out of that hole?

Plot

Team Rocket finishes digging a hole trap and disguises it with soil, leaves, and wood, though they fall into it soon after they forget its location. Meanwhile, Ash, Misty, and Pikachu arrive at the outskirts of Pewter City. As Ash takes a rest on some rocks, he and Misty meet a mysterious man named Flint, who sells rocks for a living. Flint escorts the group to the Pokémon Center, where Ash is surprised to encounter Nurse Joy again. She explains that she is the Viridian City Joy's older sister. She directs Ash's attention to a poster promoting a tournament called the Pokémon League Championship and he decides to sign up. However, before he can enter, he needs to defeat eight Pokémon Gym Leaders and earn a Gym Badge from each as proof of his victory. Flint walks in at this point and tells Ash about Pewter City's Gym Leader, Brock. He is openly skeptical of Ash's chances of winning and laughs scornfully at the very thought of it. Over a meal, Misty warns Ash of Gym Leaders' prodigious skill and offers him advice. Misty becomes angry when Ash declines her advice, so she choose to walks off, leaving him with the bill.

Ash stops by the Pokémon Center again to pick up his healed team before making his way to the Pewter Gym. When he arrives, the Gym is dark, though he soon meets the Gym Leader Brock, and challenges him to a battle. Brock queries Ash, and he replies that he has been traveling with Pikachu for two weeks. With a snap of his fingers, Brock transforms the Gym into a rocky field and turns on the lights. In the Pewter Gym, battles are two against two. Ash begins the match with Pikachu while Brock starts off with Onix. Pikachu is intimidated by the giant Pokémon and doesn't want to battle, but Ash responds by telling Pikachu that this is his battle. Pikachu's Thunder Shock is woefully ineffective against Onix's Bind, which begins to crush Pikachu, inflicting visible pain. This prompts Ash to recall Pikachu to his Poké Ball, though the attempt is thwarted by the larger Pokémon's bulk. Ash cannot bear to watch Pikachu's suffering and he forfeits the match.

As a dejected Ash leaves the Gym, he encounters Flint again, who suggests that Ash follow him to his home. Ash agrees, and over some tea, they discuss what happened in the Gym. Flint notices that Ash is obviously upset over his loss, so he consoles him with the knowledge that Brock could be an even better Trainer than he already is. Ash becomes confused by this, but Flint refuses to elaborate. Instead, he leads Ash outside to peer over a hedge into another house. The two of them watch as Brock, dressed in a pink apron, cares for his nine little brothers and sisters. Walking through the city, Flint explains that after Brock's good-for-nothing father left home to become a Pokémon Trainer, his heartbroken mother abandoned them, leaving the eldest child, Brock, to take care of his siblings. Ash feels sympathy for Brock but is determined to defeat him nonetheless. Flint recognizes Ash's determination and mentions that he might know of a way Ash can super-charge Pikachu.

Flint and Ash travel to a hydroelectric plant, where Flint hooks up the generator to the electric sacs in Pikachu's cheeks. As the river is bone-dry, Ash must run on a large water wheel to generate the electricity, which flows into Pikachu. Misty shows up and offers to lend Ash her Water-type Pokémon. However, Ash refuses and continues charging Pikachu until the generator overloads and Pikachu's electricity lights up the night sky. The next day, Ash returns with confidence to the Pewter City Gym for a rematch. Brock is also confident after his easy victory in the last battle, and the two quickly start the rematch. Brock starts off with Geodude, while Ash sends out Pidgeotto. However, the Normal- and Flying-type Pokémon cannot hurt Geodude, and is knocked out. Ash recalls it and sends out Pikachu. Misty watches and cheers for Ash from the rafters, though she is later outnumbered by Brock's supportive siblings.

Brock comments on how weak Pikachu and Ash are, and Ash retorts by commanding Pikachu's attack, which easily knocks Geodude out. Both Brock and Misty are stunned at this. Brock recalls his Geodude and sends out Onix, and a fearful Pikachu tries another Electric attack, damaging the Gym instead. Onix wraps Pikachu with Bind, but Pikachu makes a comeback with his new attack, Thunderbolt. While the attack manages to injure Onix, the Rock Snake Pokémon's Bind proves to be too much for Pikachu to handle, and the Thunderbolt fizzles out. Just as Pikachu is about to pass out, Brock suddenly spares him by calling Onix off. He tells Ash to forfeit again before any more harm comes to Pikachu. Ash protests, wanting to finish the battle.

Suddenly, the Gym's sprinklers are set off by a fire caused by Pikachu's earlier Electric attack. Water sprays all over Onix, weakening it and allowing Pikachu to fight back with another Electric attack after Misty yells out to Ash that Rock types like Onix are weakened by water. Just as Ash is about to command Pikachu to finish Onix off, Brock's brothers and sisters all crowd Ash and beg him to stop. Brock orders his brothers and sisters to not get involved, but they protest, knowing that Brock's love of Pokémon would make it painful for him to continue the match and watch his Onix get hurt further. At this, Ash, flashing back to Brock telling his Onix to release Pikachu just prior to the sprinklers being set off, calls back his Pikachu. He explains that if he defeated Brock now, it would only be because of the sprinklers being set off. He decides he wants to win his Badge fair and square, much to Misty's disappointment since he is giving up a lucky advantage.

Ash leaves the Pewter Gym and apologizes to Pikachu for being so tough on him. He turns around after hearing someone calling, and notices Brock running up to him. Surprisingly, Brock gives him the Boulder Badge. Ash doesn't want to accept the Badge, but Brock insists that Ash has earned it through his kindness to Pokémon. Brock continues to explain that rather than becoming a great Pokémon Trainer, his dream is to become a great Pokémon Breeder, but can't do so because of his family duties. He gives Ash the Badge and asks him to fulfill his dream, to which Ash agrees.

Suddenly, Flint reappears and removes his beard and hat, revealing that he is Brock's father. He explains that he avoided returning to his family as a failure of a Pokémon Trainer. Ash puzzles over the fact that Flint helped him instead of his son, Brock, and Flint explains that Ash's helplessness reminded him of himself. Flint is ready to take back the responsibilities that he abandoned years ago, which Brock returns to him, along with a long list of tasks for him to remember while taking care of the children. That evening, Ash and Brock travel on the road out of Pewter City. Ash insists that he is glad to have him along. However, Misty is a different story, and from several paces behind she yells at him to not forget about her bike. Ash and Pikachu, followed by Brock, run ahead to lose Misty, though she remains in pursuit.

Meanwhile, Team Rocket finally manages to burst out of their trap via power drill, only to end up being trampled by Ash and his friends.

Major events

Brock giving Ash the Boulder Badge

• Ash and Misty reach Pewter City.
• Ash learns about the Pokémon League, Gym Leaders, and Gym Badges.
• Ash and Misty meet Brock, the Pewter Gym Leader, and his father, Flint.
• Ash has his first Gym battle at the Pewter Gym against Brock and forfeits, suffering his first loss.
• Ash's Pikachu learns Thunderbolt.
• Ash has a rematch with Brock, but eventually forfeits again.
• Brock follows Ash and gives him his first Badge, the Boulder Badge.
• Brock joins Ash and Misty, leaving the Pewter Gym in his father's care.

For a list of all major events in the anime, please see the history page.

Debuts

Humans

• Flint
• Brock
• Brock's siblings
  • Forrest
  • Salvadore
  • Yolanda
  • Tommy
  • Cindy
  • Suzie
  • Timmy
  • Billy
  • Tilly

Pokémon debuts

• Brock's Onix
• Geodude (Brock's)

Characters

Dare da?

Humans

• Ash
• Misty
• Brock
• Jessie
• James
• Nurse Joy
• Flint
• Brock's siblings
  • Forrest

Pokémon

Who's That Pokémon?

Who's That Pokémon?: Onix

• Pikachu (Ash's)
• Meowth (Team Rocket)
• Pidgeotto (Ash's)
• Onix (Brock's)
• Geodude (Brock's; debut)

Trivia

• This was chosen by Okazaki Taiiku as the eighth episode of Pocket Monsters Premier 10.
• This episode introduces Team Rocket's pitfall trap gag.
• This episode establishes the fact that there are multiple Nurse Joys who are all part of a large extended family.
• This is the first episode in which Team Rocket appears but has no effect on the plot.
• The poster in the Pokémon Center uses type symbols from the TCG, specifically, from top to bottom, the Lightning, Psychic, Grass, Fighting, Fire, and Water symbols.
• This is the only episode where Ash tries to actively recall Pikachu back into his Poké Ball.
• This episode introduced the greatest number of named recurring characters in the anime, due to the presence of Brock's siblings. This record was later matched by The Pendant That Starts It All (Part One).
• When the full moon is first shown in this episode, a wolf can be faintly heard howling in the background.
• This episode is featured on Volume 20: Onix from VIZ Media's Pokémon All-Stars series.
• This episode aired in the United States three days before Ash won his eighth Badge in the Japanese airings.
• Ash mentions that it had nearly been two weeks since he started on his journey in this episode.
• Brock's siblings restraining Ash is similar to a scene in the series Star of the Giants.
• This episode introduces the concept of Pokémon Breeders, which wouldn't appear in the games until two generations later.
• In the English dub, the title card is written in all caps.

Errors

Ash's eyes

• The blurb incorrectly refers to the Boulder Badge as the Rock Badge.
• Before Ash's first battle with Brock, right before Brock switches the lights of the Gym on, Ash's eyes are colored red. This also happens when Ash attempts to recall Pikachu.
• When Ash begins both of his battles with Brock, the giant rock in the middle of the platform that moved into position disappears.
• When Flint tells Ash to come with him, Ash's right glove is missing.
• Ash's advantage over Brock should not have technically worked; Ground-type Pokémon are immune to Electric-type moves. This is the first of many times Pikachu's Electric attacks defy type matchups to change the results of the battle.
  • However, there are multiple future instances in the anime where Electric moves have not worked against Ground-type Pokémon, including Onix.
• In the English dub:
  • Ash tells Flint that his goal is to become a Pokémon Trainer. This is untrue, as he already is a Pokémon Trainer. His true goal is to become a Pokémon Master.
  • Flint says that Brock has ten little brothers and sisters when he only has nine. The same mistake appears in the blurb.
    • He also says that Brock's mother died after trying to raise the family on her own. However, she appears in A Family That Battles Together Stays Together!, as well as in several other episodes afterward. In the original version, he instead said that Brock's mother left the family to Brock's care.
  • When Brock says, "Geodude, go!" during his rematch with Ash, his mouth does not move when he says "go!".
• In the Brazilian Portuguese dub, Nurse Joy refers to Ash's Pidgeotto and Butterfree as only one Pokémon.

Changes

Dub edits

• Kanto Pokérap: Day 5 (Version 2)
• Flint charges a $2 fee for sitting on his rocks, or ¥50 in the Japanese version.
• The restaurant bill was changed from ¥1150 to $1150. The top of the bill's writing is removed and bottom of the bill is changed from "Restaurant Nibi" to "Thank You".

• 

  The Pokémon League poster (original)

• 

  The Pokémon League poster (dub)

• 

  The restaurant bill (original)

• 

  The restaurant bill (dub)

• 

  The Pewter Gym (original)

• 

  The Pewter Gym (dub)

• 

  Flint's sign (original)

• 

  Flint's sign (dub)

• 

  Flint's house (original)

• 

  Flint's house (dub)

Differences between the episode and the comic adaptation

• The scene where Ash discovers the poster has some extra lines in the comic (namely, Ash explicitly stating he was going to enter his name to the registration board, and Misty explicitly denying he'll do it) that weren't present in the anime.
• The scene at the diner was omitted. As a result, the subplot where Misty offers to aid Ash by letting him borrow her Pokémon was downplayed to the extent that the only hint that existed was Misty's exclamation to Ash during the fight that Rock Pokémon are weak to Water attacks late into the comic.
• When observing Brock raising his siblings at Flint's prompting, Ash explicitly says Brock's name in addition to saying "huh?" in the comic. In the episode, he only gives a confused remark.
• The scene where Brock's siblings interfere with the match is excised significantly to only show them telling off Ash and his attempting to claim he is not a bully. It also omits the flashback to Brock refusing to finish off Pikachu that ultimately has Ash decide to do a similar act of refusing to finish off Onix.
• Misty's complaint about Ash forfeiting again was cut. Likewise, Brock's reaction to Ash's explanation for throwing the match was changed to him saying his name instead of saying "Maybe..."
• Team Rocket falling into the hole again was cut out in the ending.

In other languages

Language		Title
Arabic		الوصول الى مدينة بيوتر
Bulgarian		Изпитание в град Пютър
Valencian		Combat en la Ciutat Platejada
Chinese	Cantonese	比卡超要進行特訓 * 尼比市的決鬥 * 深灰道館的決鬥！ *
	Mandarin	尼比市的決鬥！/ 尼比市的决斗！
Czech		Zápas v Cínovém městě
Danish		Dysten I Pewter City
Dutch		Krachtmeting in Pewter City
Finnish		Välit selviksi Pewter Cityssä
French	Canada	Duel à Pewter Cité
	Europe	Confrontation à Argenta
German		Showdown in Marmoria City
Greek		Αναμέτρηση στην Πόλη Πιούτερ
Hebrew		התחרות בעיר פיוטר Ha'takharut ba'Eer Pewter
Hindi		Pewter City मे मुकाबला! Pewter city me Muquabla! * शोडाउन इन Pewter City Showdown in Pewter city! *
Hungarian		Az ónvárosi küzdelem
Italian		La grande sfida * Chiarimento a Plumbeopoli *
Korean		포켓몬 매니저 웅! Pokémon maenijeo ung!
Norwegian		Oppgjør i Pewter by
Polish		Spotkanie w Marmorii
Portuguese	Brazil	Exibição na Cidade de Pewter
	Portugal	Confronto na Cidade de Pewter
Romanian		Confruntare în Orașul Pewter
Russian		Схватка в Пьютере
Serbian		Обрачун у граду Пјутер
Spanish	Latin America	¡Batalla en ciudad Plateada!
	Spain	Combate en la Ciudad Plateada * Combate en Ciudad Plateada *
Swedish		Uppgörelsen i staden Pewter * Dusten i Pewter City *
Turkish		Pewter Şehri'nde Bir Gösteri * Pewter Şehri'ndeki Hesaplaşma *
Ukrainian		Пригода в місті Пьютер
Vietnamese		Trận đấu ở thành phố Nibi

This episode article is part of Project Anime, a Bulbapedia project that covers all aspects of the Pokémon anime.