84
edits
Talk:Pokémon world in relation to the real world: Difference between revisions
From Bulbapedia, the community-driven Pokémon encyclopedia.
Jump to navigationJump to search
Talk:Pokémon world in relation to the real world (view source)
Revision as of 08:30, 17 February 2024
, 17 February→Comprehensive map
Jump Drive (talk | contribs) |
|||
| Line 1,060: | Line 1,060: | ||
:::::::In terms of either using regional/continental maps or the global map, I am fine either way. I also agree with removing Kitakami because of its vagueness in location. However, I'm not in favor of adding the spin off and side regions, for the reason why [[User:HoennMaster|<b><font color="darkblue">Hoenn</font></b>]][[User talk:HoennMaster|<b><font color="darkgreen">Master</font></b>]] removed the original global map and I think it'd be too cluttered. As I said before, it's probably best to separate the spin off and side regions from the main regions for clarity. I'll give the continental maps an update. I'll update the global map as well, just in case it's needed.[[User:Pipcrew|Pipcrew]] ([[User talk:Pipcrew|talk]]) 09:30, 29 January 2024 (UTC) | :::::::In terms of either using regional/continental maps or the global map, I am fine either way. I also agree with removing Kitakami because of its vagueness in location. However, I'm not in favor of adding the spin off and side regions, for the reason why [[User:HoennMaster|<b><font color="darkblue">Hoenn</font></b>]][[User talk:HoennMaster|<b><font color="darkgreen">Master</font></b>]] removed the original global map and I think it'd be too cluttered. As I said before, it's probably best to separate the spin off and side regions from the main regions for clarity. I'll give the continental maps an update. I'll update the global map as well, just in case it's needed.[[User:Pipcrew|Pipcrew]] ([[User talk:Pipcrew|talk]]) 09:30, 29 January 2024 (UTC) | ||
:::::::I think it makes sense to include the side regions on a map at least somewhere in the article, even if the locations for some side regions are more speculation than confirmed. The fact that they're described in the article means that should probably be reflected in the maps intended for use on that article right? Pipcrew suggested making separate maps for the spinoff regions and including those maps under the spinoff region header and I think that may be a good compromise. --[[User:Jump Drive|Jump Drive]] ([[User talk:Jump Drive|talk]]) 17:31, 16 February 2024 (UTC) | :::::::I think it makes sense to include the side regions on a map at least somewhere in the article, even if the locations for some side regions are more speculation than confirmed. The fact that they're described in the article means that should probably be reflected in the maps intended for use on that article right? Pipcrew suggested making separate maps for the spinoff regions and including those maps under the spinoff region header and I think that may be a good compromise. --[[User:Jump Drive|Jump Drive]] ([[User talk:Jump Drive|talk]]) 17:31, 16 February 2024 (UTC) | ||
::::::::I agree with Jump Drive, that if the side/spinoff regions were to have a map, it's best for them to be separate from the main series as the compromise and label it as a speculative map rather than an affirmative/factual map as the main series maps are. Give a description like "this is a map of x showing where the side/spin-off regions are most likely to be". This page is already labeled as speculation, so I think it's viable, only if it's placed on the appropriate section [[Pokémon_world_in_relation_to_the_real_world#In_the_spin-off_games|here]]. | |||
:::::::: To reiterate and summarize my reasoning for a separate map rather than a merged map with all regions on it, is that 1: I think it's best to keep it simple and clear for the reader, to remove/limit the possibility of overlap (looking at the map, part of Almia would be part of Sinnoh and it would be part of Hisui in this map [[File:Hisui.png|200px]]). Future main series regions may overlap with the side/spin-off series. 2: The main series is a separate definitional entity from the side/spinoff regions (whether or not they are referenced). Having them separate would make it clear to a new reader that x region is a main series region. 3. The main series has a more confirmed location than the side/spin off regions. This is not just in its shape, but the culture and buildings etc the main series regions have.[[User:Pipcrew|Pipcrew]] ([[User talk:Pipcrew|talk]]) 08:29, 17 February 2024 (UTC) | |||
== Regarding TCG Holon Region == | == Regarding TCG Holon Region == | ||
