Talk:Pokémon aircraft

Latest comment: 2 August by SnorlaxMonster in topic Wikimedia inclusion problem

Wikimedia inclusion problem

Hello, all! Thanks for having me on Bulbapedia and the wider Bulbagarden community in these few years. I'll be brief here at the start and you-all be my plumbers to add more proverbial pipes to the expanding water-works.

Much of the files here on the article (particularly under the original ANA aircraft heading) are or were in one method or another "extracted" from Wikimedia Commons, and since 2025 because of some (mis)interpretation of the Japanese Copyright Law deletion requests were made on hundreds of files uploaded from the late 2000s onwards. We have strived to make the corresponding Wikipedia article (archived 2024) on this subject to be somewhat better than here, but unfortunately Commons' policies have been overlooked and now because those are cited after almost 20 years of gray-area tolerance the files were deleted or are in peril of deletion. Discussion about one nominator's actions is ongoing as of typing this, and it's kind of not being in the favor of keeping files that were in the past. A fellow POKéTalker and a native-speaker probably versed in the law, among others, have tried so hard to keep these at bay but they are on the losing side. So I would want to discuss the next steps of migrating what files still left there and those can can be taken up by undeletion requests for potential migration to the Bulbagarden Archives, as an alternative to uploading to a handful language Wikipedias with the necessary non-free use rationale templates, cited as a counterproductive plan B for Commons uploaders and Wikipedians alike. Appreciate further communication with the wider Bulbagarden community for their expertise and views before they get out of hand. Thanks so much! Carltonus (talk) 06:09, 2 August 2026 (UTC)Reply

Bulbapedia would certainly be interested in hosting images of Pokémon aircraft we are currently missing (or better quality replacements for images we already have), regardless of the outcome of any Wikimedia Common discussion. If you have identified images on Wikimedia Commons that would merit being included on this page, feel free to upload them.
It sounds like there is some kind of dispute as to whether the photographers of those images actually have sufficient rights to the image to release them under the free licenses they are currently tagged as on Wikimedia Commons. When uploading to the Bulbagarden Archives, I think it would be important to note the licenses that the original photographers licensed their images as (so that it's clear they're happy for their photographs to be used). If you believe there are legitimate concerns about the possibility of copyright on the liveries applying to the photographs of the liveries, you should include some kind of disclaimer about this in the license section of the file page — but only if you personally believe there is some ambiguity here, not just that someone else on Wikimedia Commons believes that. If you do choose to include a disclaimer like that, you would need to write it in plain text — almost all images on the Bulbagarden Archives are uploaded as fair use images, so there aren't any templates that would provide that for you. We also host several images of Pokémon Jets taken from official websites under fair use rationales (like this image you uploaded), so it would not be an issue to simply host them under a fair use rationale if there was actually an issue with the copyright of the liveries attaching to the free photographs of them.
However, please note that the Bulbagarden Archives are only intended to host images for use on Bulbapedia. If there are images that don't have a use on Bulbapedia, there is no need to upload them to the Bulbagarden Archives. My thought is that if there are 7 different images of the same plane from different angles, we wouldn't need all 7 images; ideally just 2 or 3 at most to make sure the entire design is visible (although I recognize you likely will need at least 2 to show both sides of the plane). This page currently doesn't have any galleries, although it probably could benefit from some, so don't feel like the current number of images means that more would not be necessary. SnorlaxMonster 11:06, 2 August 2026 (UTC)Reply
"potential migration to the Bulbagarden Archives, as an alternative to uploading to a handful language Wikipedias with the necessary non-free use rationale templates"
To my earlier point, the Bulbagarden Archives are only intended to host images for use on Bulbapedia. If you intend to use these images on other language Wikipedias, you would still need to upload the images to those Wikipedias (with appropriate fair use rationale) rather than hotlinking them from the Bulbagarden Archives. I'm not sure if that's what you were implying there, but I just want to make this part clear. SnorlaxMonster 11:11, 2 August 2026 (UTC)Reply