User:Maxim: Difference between revisions

From Bulbapedia, the community-driven Pokémon encyclopedia.
Jump to navigationJump to search
(Sadly, I have to change my userpage into a PROTEST PAGE against the illegal voting. Please look here and discuss. It's about Bulbapedia's future.)
Line 46: Line 46:


=My protest against the results of forums voting about Pokémon redirects=
=My protest against the results of forums voting about Pokémon redirects=
With all honesty, I have to argue with the results of [http://bmgf.bulbagarden.net/showthread.php?t=86441 Official Voting on Bulbagarden Forums] concerning te changes to the current Pokémon redirect system. The voting was conducted in an unfair and manipulated way - the organizing admins didn't mention the most important consequence of the system change - the entire Bulbapedia will have to be closed from non-admin editing for at least a week in order to move all pages and update redirects/links without unneccessary problem. This means yet another unneccessary and overlong closure of Bulbapedia and yet another hurdle in its way to completeness. It is very sad that instead of going forwards in covering the Pokémon franchise, the Bulbapedia administrators prefer to waste their time on some arbitrary problems. It is also very sad that Bulbapedia administators don't fully inform their users about what they are choosing. I am sure that if the potential closure was mentioned, the voting results would be different. Also, it is very saddening that such important issues to Bulbapedia are being decided on the Forums, which prevents a percent of users (myself included) to express their opinion about the matter. Everyone should have his right to care for Bulbapedia's future. And the way the voting was done, I'm feeling purposefully excluded and discriminated (let alone the fact that my ban from Bulbagarden Forums was illegal and its explanation was sheer idiocy). For stated reasons, I sadly have to deem the voting '''ILLEGAL''' and I demand a new voting, this time on Bulbapedia (so that all users can decide, not just a part of them).
With all honesty, I have to argue with the results of [http://bmgf.bulbagarden.net/showthread.php?t=86441 Official Voting on Bulbagarden Forums] concerning te changes to the current Pokémon redirect system. The voting was conducted in an unfair and manipulated way - the organizing admins didn't mention the most important consequence of the system change - the entire Bulbapedia will have to be closed from non-admin editing for at least a week in order to move all pages and update redirects/links without unneccessary problem. This means yet another unneccessary and overlong closure of Bulbapedia and yet another hurdle in its way to completeness. It is very sad that instead of going forwards in covering the Pokémon franchise, the Bulbapedia administrators prefer to waste their time on some arbitrary problems. It is also very sad that Bulbapedia administators don't fully inform their users about what they are choosing. I am sure that if the potential closure was mentioned, the voting results would be different. Also, it is very saddening that such important issues to Bulbapedia are being decided on the Forums, which prevents a percent of users (myself included) to express their opinion about the matter. Everyone should have his right to care for Bulbapedia's future. And the way the voting was done, I'm feeling purposefully excluded and discriminated (let alone the fact that my ban from Bulbagarden Forums was illegal and its explanation was sheer idiocy). For stated reasons, I sadly have to deem the voting '''ILLEGAL''' and I demand a new voting, this time on Bulbapedia (so that all users can decide, not just a part of them and to make sure that the results aren't forged [the poll system of the forums is too easy to forge]).


This voting is just yet another example of the Bulbapedia's recent mismanagement and proves that this Wiki's situation is more than saddening. Am I the only person who really cares about this Wiki?
This voting is just yet another example of the Bulbapedia's recent mismanagement and proves that this Wiki's situation is more than saddening. Am I the only person who really cares about this Wiki?

Revision as of 19:09, 13 November 2010

IMPORTANT NOTICE: Have Pokémon Anime DVDs? Or maybe Tracey West's Novelisations? Want to help the Bulbapedia and the entire fandom? Please look here! Be involved in the greatest user action in the Bulbapedia EVER!


GMT This user uses Greenwich Mean Time, which is UTCGMT+1.
pl Polski jest językiem ojczystym tego użytkownika.
en-3 This user is able to contribute with an advanced level of English.
034.png This user identifies as male.
018.png This user comes from Poland.
475.png This user is a Catholic.
369.png This user is conservative.

Template:User Dictatorship

Spr DP Sailor.png This user uses too much vulgar language and should not speak until this habit is removed.
Chuang Yi Logo.png This user trusts Chuang Yi.
Spr BW Hilda.png This user is a Pokémon Trainer.
Spr RS Maxie.png This user is a member of Team Magma.
474.png This user contributes using Microsoft Windows Vista.
038.png This user contributes using Mozilla Firefox.
001.png This user is a non-legendary Pokémon trainer.
164.png This user doesn't get enough sleep.
133.png This user's favorite Pokémon is Eevee.
363.png This user is an Ice-type trainer.
Pikachup.png This user loves ketchup as much as Pikachu.
Bulbapedia logo.png This user dreams of Bulbapedia being complete someday.
480.png This user is intelligent.
Spr HGSS Scientist.png This user is an evil genius.
Spr HGSS Double Team.png This user is an Ace Trainer.
233.png This user spends too much time on the computer.
Spr 1b 006.png This user is a player of Pokémon Red Version.
Spr 1b 009.png This user is a player of Pokémon Blue Version.
Spr 1y 025.png This user is a player of Pokémon Yellow Version.
Spr 2g 250.png This user is a player of Pokémon Gold Version.
Spr 2s 249.png This user is a player of Pokémon Silver Version.
Spr 2g 245.png This user is a player of Pokémon Crystal Version.
Spr 3r 383.png This user is a player of Pokémon Ruby Version.
Spr 3r 384.png This user is a player of Pokémon Emerald Version.
Spr 3f 006.png This user is a player of Pokémon FireRed Version.
Spr 3f 003.png This user is a player of Pokémon LeafGreen Version.
Spr 4d 483.png This user is a player of Pokémon Diamond Version.
Stadium150.png This user is a player of Pokémon Stadium.
250.png This user is a player of Pokémon Stadium 2. 249.png
Rescue Team Badge.png This user is a player of Pokémon Mystery Dungeon.
Solana and Lunick.png This user is a player of Pokémon Ranger.

My protest against the results of forums voting about Pokémon redirects

With all honesty, I have to argue with the results of Official Voting on Bulbagarden Forums concerning te changes to the current Pokémon redirect system. The voting was conducted in an unfair and manipulated way - the organizing admins didn't mention the most important consequence of the system change - the entire Bulbapedia will have to be closed from non-admin editing for at least a week in order to move all pages and update redirects/links without unneccessary problem. This means yet another unneccessary and overlong closure of Bulbapedia and yet another hurdle in its way to completeness. It is very sad that instead of going forwards in covering the Pokémon franchise, the Bulbapedia administrators prefer to waste their time on some arbitrary problems. It is also very sad that Bulbapedia administators don't fully inform their users about what they are choosing. I am sure that if the potential closure was mentioned, the voting results would be different. Also, it is very saddening that such important issues to Bulbapedia are being decided on the Forums, which prevents a percent of users (myself included) to express their opinion about the matter. Everyone should have his right to care for Bulbapedia's future. And the way the voting was done, I'm feeling purposefully excluded and discriminated (let alone the fact that my ban from Bulbagarden Forums was illegal and its explanation was sheer idiocy). For stated reasons, I sadly have to deem the voting ILLEGAL and I demand a new voting, this time on Bulbapedia (so that all users can decide, not just a part of them and to make sure that the results aren't forged [the poll system of the forums is too easy to forge]).

This voting is just yet another example of the Bulbapedia's recent mismanagement and proves that this Wiki's situation is more than saddening. Am I the only person who really cares about this Wiki?