User:Squirtle drink/Sprite Comments

Other people have done this, so I'm going to do it too

Pokémon	Green	Red/Blue	Yellow	Gen 1 Backsprite	Gold	Silver	Crystal	Comments
Bulbasaur								RBG look really wierd, and the backsprite looks depressed... Good from Yellow onwards though
Ivysaur								Green looks really pissed off for some reason, Red and Blue is somehow standing up. The backsprite is still looking a little down. Again, good from Yellow onwards.
Venusaur								Green's plant is crushing it, while for the backsprite, you get a salad to look at. Red/Blue is actually pretty good compared to others, and it's very good from Yellow onwards.
Charmander								RBG are nightmare fuel, and the backsprite looks like it is a terribly made plush toy or something. Gold and Crystal look too goofy for my liking, but Yellow and Silver are good.
Charmeleon								Except for a decent effort in Yellow, none of these are that good! And the backsprite looks absolutely nothing like Charmeleon.
Charizard								RGB and the skeletal backsprite are terrible, but I think some of these Charizard fanboys deserve it. Yellow has just finished a meal of Venusaur Salad. Gen 2 is slightly questionable, but fine.
Squirtle								The eyes all look wierd except for Yellow, but the backsprite in Gen I is the best of the three...
Wartortle								RBG look a little off, but Yellow onwards looks fine. The backsprite looks a little wierd...
Blastoise								Green is making a scary face, while Red/Blue needs to stop adding so much ranch dressing to its Venusaur Salad! The "shell" in the backsprite looks nothing like one. Yellow onwards is very good, I like the trick he's doing in Yellow!
Caterpie								All good, except for the questionable backsprite
Metapod								All good, but I don't see why they couldn't fix the eye in Green/Backsprite...
Butterfree								These sprites are all pretty good, but Green looks stressed out... However, they didn't get the colour right until Gen III.
Weedle								Someone cut off the legs of RBG, but they're all good.
Kakuna								RBG look like the Beedrill's already come out of the cocoon, but Yellow+ is great.
Beedrill								Green looks a little too much like a real bee, which bled a little into the backsprite, but all others are fine.
Pidgey								RBG look too much like a generic bird, but others are all fine.
Pidgeotto								RBG look weird, but others are OK.
Pidgeot								Gen 1 all look wierd, while in Gold people really need to pay attention to the don't feed the birds signs...
Rattata								All pretty good
Raticate								All look fine, but Red/Blue's teeth are too big.
Spearow								Most of these look like a parrot that would be on a pirate's shoulder in cartoons! Yellow is the only one that looks like Spearow.
Fearow								The wings are wierd in RBG, but otherwise OK.
Ekans								Green has a duck beak, while Red/Blue still don't look like Ekans. Others are fine
Arbok								I hate Green, but all others are good. I wonder what's up with the wierd markings on the backsprite though...
Pikachu								RBG are fat and have a wierd looking tail. Yellow is perfect (It pretty much had to be), and it was all good from there.
Raichu								RBG have wierd faces, which transferred to the backsprite, but Yellow on are great.
Sandshrew								None of them are that good in Gen I, but Gen II are cute.
Sandslash								Again, RBG screws it up. Yellow is good, but Gen II starts the trend of making Sandslash badass.
Nidoran♀								RBG seem like pretty lazy efforts (especially the backsprite), but it's good from Yellow+
Nidorina								All of these are terrible, but most people use the Moon Stone right away so it doesn't matter too much.
Nidoqueen								Green and backsprite are horrifying, but the rest are great. Yellow wants a hug!
Nidoran♂								RBG are hideous, but the rest are OK.
Nidorino								All are good, but the backsprite looks like a copy paste of Nidorina's with a few alterations.
Nidoking								Green is pretty bad, though not as bad as Nidoqueen, all others are OK. The back sprite is questionable, but with how much I use it when I play Gen I, I'm used to it.
Clefairy								All are good, but the backsprite rustles my jimmies.
Clefable								Surprisingly, Green is the best one here! The backsprite is HUGE!
Vulpix								RBG have the usual eye issue, but all others are cute like Vulpix usually is
Ninetales								Apart from RBG, these are good. The backsprite looks creepy...
Jigglypuff								RBG look like they need more sleep, but others are great.
Wigglytuff								Green looks retarded, but the others are great.
Zubat								Except for the horrifying one in Green, these are all good. Well, as good as Zubat can look with no eyes...
Golbat								Gen I are all bad, especially Red/Blue which made fighting Team Rocket a nightmare. I like Gen II.
Oddish								It's pretty hard to get Oddish wrong, but the leaves do look in need of a trim in Green.
Gloom								The flower is wrong in Green, but otherwise fine.
Vileplume								Green's flower looks like it was drawn by a 3 year old, while Red/Blue are attempting to imitate the Kool-aid guy. Others are all good
Paras								Good, but Red/Blue should have just kept Green's sprite...
Parasect								All of these are really good, even if the mushroom is a little too big in RBG.
Venonat								All good, though RBG can do with a haircut.
Venomoth								Damn Game Freak for screwing up my favourite Pokemon in RBG! Thankfully Yellow+ is awesome.
Diglett
Dugtrio
Meowth
Persian
Psyduck
Golduck
Mankey
Primeape
Growlithe
Arcanine
Poliwag
Poliwhirl
Poliwrath
Abra
Kadabra
Alakazam
Machop
Machoke
Machamp
Bellsprout
Weepinbell
Victreebel
Tentacool
Tentacruel
Geodude
Graveler
Golem
Ponyta
Rapidash
Slowpoke
Slowbro

I will do more very soon.