User:NinegonMaster/Sprite Comments

WARNING!!! THIS PAGE IS IMAGE HEAVY!!!

Eh, why not? I just felt like this would be fun to do.

Pokémon	Green	Red/Blue	Yellow	Back	Gold	Silver	Crystal	Conclusion
Bulbasaur								Green is a bit off, but otherwise they're all fine.
Ivysaur								Green irks me and the back sprite is awfully busy, but otherwise they're okay.
Venusaur								Most of these are good, except Green which is hilariously bad. I don't know what to make of that back sprite.
Charmander								Aside from the over-shiny eyes in Green, these are fine.
Charmeleon								Green is weird but otherwise these are okay. I especially like Crystal's animation.
Charizard								Green is a derp. Otherwise these are fine.
Squirtle								RB&G are weird, but otherwise these are okay.
Wartortle								Most of these are okay, though the body shaking in Crystal is hilariously off. Green is a derp, like most of them.
Blastoise								RB is fat, Green has a weird smile, and Yellow is a nutjob. Otherwise these are good.
Caterpie								Dear Arceus the back sprite is fail. Otherwise these are fine.
Metapod								RB&G and the back sprite are weird but otherwise these are fine.
Butterfree								S'all good. Especially Silver.
Weedle								Silver is drunk and RB&G are missing feet. Otherwise good.
Kakuna								RB has the mysterious arms and Green is off-proportion. Otherwise good.
Beedrill								S'all good, except Green which is weird.
Pidgey								RB&G's beady eyes bug me. Otherwise okay.
Pidgeotto								Crystal is afraid its eyes are gonna dry out, look at it blink! Otherwise, s'all good.
Pidgeot								These are all just fine, except fatty-fatty Gold.
Rattata								The butt shake in Crystal is hilarious. RB&G's tails are too thin. Yellow is weird.
Raticate								RB is weird, but otherwise these are okay.
Spearow								RB&G's beaks are too big. Otherwise just fine.
Fearow								These are all great sprites! Kudos to the R/B/G spriters on this one.
Ekans								That is so Bellsprout wearing an Ekans costume in Green, and the back sprite has arms. Otherwise, these are alright.
Arbok								Green's head is WAY too small. Otherwise fine.
Pikachu								Green's a bit weird and RB is fat. Yellow is PERFECT. S'all good from there.
Raichu								Green is a derp, and they're all fat. I love Gold though, he's like "YOU CANNOT IGNORE MY GIRTH >=D"
Sandshrew								Weird in RB&G, otherwise okay.
Sandslash								Back sprite, stop looking at me. Otherwise these are alright.
Nidoran♀								They're meh up until Silver. Yellow fell over.
Nidorina								RB has quite a snout but otherwise these are fine.
Nidoqueen								Green is a SERIOUS derp and the backsprite is fail. RB is great. These are all fine otherwise.
Nidoran♂								R/B/G and the back sprite are HORRIBLE.
Nidorino								I actually love the Green sprite here. Otherwise they're all good.
Nidoking								Green has way too big of eyes. RB is alright, Yellow is weird. I like the backsprite.
Clefairy								I love the dazed, confused look on Green's face. It's so cute like that. Also, the Crystal animation is adorable.
Clefable								WHAT THE HECK IS THAT THING FROM YELLOW!?
Vulpix								Back sprite is a PUNK ROCKAH! Just look at that mohawk! Green looks like a plushie, I wanna snuggle it.
Ninetales								I actually like Green, and I know where they were going with RB (they just didn't do it right). Otherwise good.
Jigglypuff								RB&G are epic fail. Yellow is sort of good. Good onward.
Wigglytuff								OH ARCEUS THE GREEN SPRITE. *Runs away*
Zubat								Green is derpy. Otherwise alright.
Golbat								R/B's tongue is epic fail. Yellow is mega derpy. Otherwise okay.
Oddish								S'all good.
Gloom								Yellow is glowing and RB&G are fail.
Vileplume								Yellow looks evil, and RB&G paid too much attention to the flower and not enough to Vileplume himself.
Paras								Green is drunk and RB is so much fail.
Parasect								S'all good. I especially love the Yellow sprite, he's all "In your face, sucka!"
Venonat								Flashing eyes in Crystal are not approved. Otherwise good.
Venomoth								RB&G and the back sprite are hideous. Otherwise, perfectly fine.
Diglett								Perfectly fine.
Dugtrio								Perfectly fine.
Meowth								Green is fat and I love RB to death. Otherwise good.
Persian								It's all good.
Psyduck								RB made me lol. Otherwise fine.
Golduck								Loving 'em all except Green.
Mankey								It's an amoeba in RB&G.
Primeape								Roadkill in Green, otherwise good.
Growlithe								S'all good. (Yes, even the back sprite.)
Arcanine								RB&G are kind of awkward. Yellow is sweet.
Poliwag								Not bad after Yellow.
Poliwhirl								It's derp until Yellow.
Poliwrath								It looks like it came straight smack out of Mega Man. Especially the Green sprite.
Abra								Gold's eye is open. Otherwise good.
Kadabra								S'all good.
Alakazam								Green is incredibly awkward, but otherwise they're good.
Machop								RB is cute. Green is a derp.
Machoke								Gen 1 is weird. It's a girl in G/S (look at that chest XD). Before you ask, I myself am a girl, I just had to pull that joke.
Machamp								OH ARCEUS KILL THE GREEN ONE WITH FIRE.
Bellsprout								Fine from Yellow onward.
Weepinbell								Same as Bellsprout.
Victreebel								S'all good.
Tentacool								Same as Victreebel.
Tentacruel								I love its RB sprite. XD
Geodude								Green is what is this I don't even, RB is funny. Otherwise good.
Graveler								They all just look wrong. RB one has a likable facial expression, though.
Golem								Awkward until Gen. II.
Ponyta								I like them all.
Rapidash								Green's flames look like fins.
Slowpoke								All derp, but that's normal for Slowpoke.
Slowbro								Green is likable. Otherwise, meh.

That's all. Here's page 2.