Talk:Crescent Isle

Game-exclusive items?

Can someone with Omega Ruby test which items appear on Crescent Isle when it appears naturally? This probably requires that you haven't caught Cresselia, because I caught Cresslia previously in my OR game, and now Crescent Isle seems not to appear any more (whereas on my AS game, it's been appearing once every week or two, on average (though I don't have a huge data set)).

On Alpha Sapphire, I've been sitting on Crescent Isle for a few days, and I'm getting Heart Scale, Deep Sea Tooth, and Razor Fang. I suspect on OR you would get Heart Scale, Deep Sea Scale, and Razor Claw. So I'd like someone with OR to check their Crescent Isle. If you still have Crescent Isle appearing naturally in OR and if you can save on the island without picking up the hidden item, you can check what the hidden item is each day (it will change, sooner or later), and soon enough (within a week probably) you should be able to tell if you can get Deep Sea Scale and Razor Claw.

There are a couple ways this assumption could be wrong even if someone sees Deep Sea Scale and Razor Claw in OR, but they're relatively more difficult to check, so I'd be happy to just trust that the simplest, most logical answer is true: that they're game-exclusives. Tiddlywinks (talk) 15:40, 15 April 2015 (UTC)

Well, nevermind, then. I actually found a Deep Sea Scale in AS. The weird thing is, it seems to be on a different "slot" than the Deep Sea Tooth (though of course, since Crescent Isle has more than 3 possible items, there's certainly a little more to slots than the other Mirage spots alone would suggest). Tiddlywinks (talk) 06:12, 17 April 2015 (UTC)

FWIW, I just got a natural Crescent Isle in my OR game. It just took a couple months... (Of course, there's a couple regular Mirage spots I still haven't seen naturally in either of my games either. It's hard to be sure, but Crescent Isle may just have the same flat chance as any other daily Mirage spot.) Tiddlywinks (talk) 14:02, 17 May 2015 (UTC)