Talk:Silver (Lugia): Difference between revisions
From Bulbapedia, the community-driven Pokémon encyclopedia.
Jump to navigationJump to search
(oops) |
|||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
I think this article should be moved. I don't know to what, but Silver (Johto) is misleading and vague: i looked at the disambig for "Silver", and noticed that Black, Silver from Pokemon adventures, {{tt|the Silver counterpart from Pocket Monsters|i forgot his name}} are all from Johto, Mt. Silver is in Johto, Silver/Soulsilver take place in Johto and Silver (Game) is also from Johto. Should we change it? [[User:Flyingtypefan|Flyingtypefan]] 05:32, 12 August 2010 (UTC) | I think this article should be moved. I don't know to what, but Silver (Johto) is misleading and vague: i looked at the disambig for "Silver", and noticed that Black, Silver from Pokemon adventures, {{tt|the Silver counterpart from Pocket Monsters|i forgot his name}} are all from Johto, Mt. Silver is in Johto, Silver/Soulsilver take place in Johto and Silver (Game) is also from Johto. Should we change it? [[User:Flyingtypefan|Flyingtypefan]] 05:32, 12 August 2010 (UTC) | ||
:IN ORDER: | |||
:*{{obp|Black|Golden Boys}}, like {{obp|Gold|Golden Boys}} and {{obp|Chris|Golden Boys}}. | |||
:*{{adv|Silver}}, like {{adv|Gold}}, {{adv|Red}}, {{adv|Blue}}, {{adv|Green}}, {{adv|Yellow}}, and the others. | |||
:*[[Ginjirō]], like [[Kinnosuke]] and the others. | |||
:*[[Mt. Silver]] needing disambiguation is like saying [[Mt. Moon]] or [[Mt. Ember]] needs it. Since, you know. Everyone searches Mt. Ember if they mean {{m|Ember|the move}}. | |||
:*{{game|Silver}} and {{game|SoulSilver}}, like all other games, wouldn't have a region disambiguation. | |||
:*{{ga|Silver}} is from Johto... and? So is {{ga|Gold}}. And {{ga|Kris}}. And {{ga|Lyra}}. | |||
:We don't need to change it. Only thing I can see it coming in conflict with is {{an|Silver}}, who everyone can assume is Ash's dad forever. And you get a description of who this Silver is on the disambiguation page. Next to nothing links here, anyway. And when it does, it's made pretty damn clear that ''this is a Lugia'', not a mountain or a game or some jerk with red hair. '''[[User:TTEchidna|<span style="color:#FF0000">''TTE''</span>]][[User talk:TTEchidna|chidna]]''' 09:39, 12 August 2010 (UTC) | |||
Revision as of 09:39, 12 August 2010
Trivia
Could someone re-word the trivia including the reference to movie canon in the anime episode to make it sound better? --いぬみみ 00:58, 10 December 2008 (UTC)
Proposed move
I think this article should be moved. I don't know to what, but Silver (Johto) is misleading and vague: i looked at the disambig for "Silver", and noticed that Black, Silver from Pokemon adventures, the Silver counterpart from Pocket Monsters are all from Johto, Mt. Silver is in Johto, Silver/Soulsilver take place in Johto and Silver (Game) is also from Johto. Should we change it? Flyingtypefan 05:32, 12 August 2010 (UTC)
- IN ORDER:
- Black, like Gold and Chris.
- Silver, like Gold, Red, Blue, Green, Yellow, and the others.
- Ginjirō, like Kinnosuke and the others.
- Mt. Silver needing disambiguation is like saying Mt. Moon or Mt. Ember needs it. Since, you know. Everyone searches Mt. Ember if they mean the move.
- Pokémon Silver and Pokémon SoulSilver, like all other games, wouldn't have a region disambiguation.
- Silver is from Johto... and? So is Gold. And Kris. And Lyra.
- We don't need to change it. Only thing I can see it coming in conflict with is Silver, who everyone can assume is Ash's dad forever. And you get a description of who this Silver is on the disambiguation page. Next to nothing links here, anyway. And when it does, it's made pretty damn clear that this is a Lugia, not a mountain or a game or some jerk with red hair. TTEchidna 09:39, 12 August 2010 (UTC)
