Talk:Violet

From Bulbapedia, the community-driven Pokémon encyclopedia.
Jump to: navigation, search

Yes, in my opinion I would love to see Violet's page to be moved to The Sensational Sisters, because these three sisters are mostly seen all together. It makes sense to add her to the Sensational Sisters page. All three of them run the gym together, and always look after it, therefore Misty has no worries going on an adventure with Ash and Brock. Honestly speaking, I don't know even if there was a time when all three sisters have been separated. I feel like when there was Daisy in the room, that meant that Violet and Lily were in it too. I feel like she does fit better in the Sensational Sisters page, because she is part of the Sensational Sisters, she is not separated. Just from looking at their pictures, I know the 1st season of Pokemon still had great graphics, but it's not as amazing as the graphics from X and Y anime, for example. Anyway, I noticed that all three Cerulean Sisters have a similar face. I just noticed that, that's so odd. Well, they are sisters for a fact. So what I mentioned is just my opinion, and I also respect everyone else, and their opinions.

FitzSimmons5423 (talk) 15:30, 28 July 2018 (UTC)

Disambig

Should this be disambig'd too? After all, there is Violet City... --TTEchidna 15:53, 4 March 2007 (UTC)

Honestly, I'm against the idea. Ever since May got moved to May (anime), I've been going through every single link to it and fixing it. It's such a time-consuming task. I suppose with a character like Violet, who hasn't appeared in too many episodes, it woudn't be too bad, but just the same. --PAK Man 16:14, 4 March 2007 (UTC)

Merger with the sensational sisters page

To my fellow users,

I believe this page should be merged with The Sensational Sisters page, given that the three sisters tend to appear together, much like all off Brock's siblings or Lana's sister's Harper and Sarah. In Forrest's case, he appeared by himself when he became the new Pewter City Gym Leader and therefore a dedicated page to him is required. Though as for Misty's siblings, the differences in their personalities and physical appearances, and some Pokémon, are the only differences, but they can be explained on one page. The sisters pride themselves on being a trio, and given that their few appearances have always been together little more information can be detailed to further differentiate them from each other. And reading the other two's pages, the history sections are all identical, which are also identical to The Sensational Sisters information, so why not merge them together. A redirect page and even a page rename such as "Daisy, Lily and Violet (The Sensational Sisters)" could even be considered t account for the merger. Hope to hear back from others. PardescanSlowbro (talk) 06:04, 21 July 2018 (UTC)

Definitely agree. These characters are minor ones, and don't deserve to have their own articles. Striker212 (talk) 23:10, 15 November 2018 (UTC)
Oppose. They're major enough to deserve their own articles. And Daisy was given more focus than her sisters in Chronicles, so it's not like they're glued to each other. I think we should consider expanding their respective articles, rather than merging them. --Maxim (talk) 21:36, 16 November 2018 (UTC)
I'm all in for keeping Daisy's article separate while merging Violet and Lily's articles into the Sensational Sisters article. Those two do not seem to be as fleshed out as their other sisters in terms of characterization. GrammarFreak01 (talk) 21:39, 16 November 2018 (UTC)
By the way, the fact that we don't have separate pages for characters such as Go-Rock Quads or Prof. Willow's Assistants doesn't mean that it's a good trend and that we should spread it to similar cases. Actually, I think we should be seeking to unmerge the merged pages, rather than the other way around. More information is better than less information. --Maxim (talk) 21:42, 16 November 2018 (UTC)
I'm usually for more information, but duplicating everything as in this case is of no benefit. The history sections are identical, with only the Pokémon and character sections of any difference. Interesting idea GrammarFreak01, I think a re-write of Daisy's article could help individualize it more especially given her separate appearances in the chronicles, but the other two have not appeared by themselves. Also, I would like to make note that three Trainers called Lily, Daisy and Violet appear in the Cerulean Gym in the Let's Go games, but i'm not sure of the nature of the connection to the anime characters. If those characters were connected to the the anime ones, that might be enough to keep them separate. I noticed the three sisters are missing manga sections, with only details on any manga appearances listed on the sensational sisters page.PardescanSlowbro (talk) 13:51, 18 November 2018 (UTC)
Maxim, I notice you didn't mention Sakura's sisters. By that logic, would those characters be separated into their own articles? If you don't think so, what exactly would be a preferred criteria for creating articles for members of a group like the Sensational Sisters? GrammarFreak01 (talk) 21:35, 18 November 2018 (UTC)