Template talk:Regions
Why is the Johto Region League listed as "Silver Conference"? It's anime-only. The template is supposed to be game-based, isn't it. - unsigned comment from Maxim (talk • contribs)
- Orange Islands are on there. Therefore, we can assume it's cross-canon. By the way, please remember to sign your comments. --Pie 17:12, 21 September 2006 (UTC)
Cross-Canon? The name "Silver Conference" is not mentioned in games and the league is in Indigo Plateau not Mt. Silver. That's not cross canon! I think it should say: "Silver Conference at Mt. Silver in anime, Johto League at Indigo Plateau in the games." But that require too much space - Maxim
- When I made the template yesterday, I tried to make it so that it would divide between, making the one for Indigo Plateau go under the Johto section as well as the Silver conference, but I wasn't able to. I was attempting to make it cross-canon, just like how the pages on the regions, professors, and teams are. However, it didn't render right, and it would've looked a bit weird anyway, so I left it as just Silver Conference for Johto. Then it was for game canon vs. show canon that I didn't make the Orange TR the same square as the Sevii TR. I'll try to remedy it somehow... Tom Temprotran 06:04, 23 September 2006 (UTC)
Actually, the Map Item on Sevii Islands is a Town Map and a Sevii Islands Location (Mt. Ember) is featured in H018 - Maxim
Geez... that is a huge template...--PikamasterADV 18:57, 25 September 2006 (UTC)
Got some Questions:
1. Should the Town Map be used for the Sevii Islands? Since that is the Map Item you have in the games you can go there?
2. Why isn't Orre listed as Generation III? It is playable in games compatable with the 3rd Gen Adventures --PikamasterADV 23:12, 28 September 2006 (UTC)
Fixed the Sevii anime status; I didn't realize that there was yet an episode featured there, but can you blame me? It's not even aired here yet... And the Town map for Sevii... eh, I suppose. As for why Orre's not part of Gen III, it's mostly because it's in what I consider to be more of a side game that's merely compatible with Gen III. I just used the main series, anyway, it'd be like putting White City in the template as well. Sure, Stadium 2 was compatible with Gen II, but it wasn't really part of the main series. Also, it'd be like putting Ranger in Gen IV. Tom Temprotran 07:10, 29 September 2006 (UTC)
Doesn't kanto, the orange and sevii island shared the smae pokedex? Pokeant 14:48, 4 November 2006 (UTC)
- Sevii and Orange are debatable. In all technicalities, the Sevii Islands have the Kanto region's dex since they were in FRLG and are more closely connected... but really, they don't have their own specifically... no trainers we've played as got a Pokédex there. As for Orange, since the Anime never states explicitly any difference in order even in Hoenn, and there are even Kanto-only Pokémon there... eh, just leave them as having no regional dex order (which, by default would be the National Dex, anyway, far as I see it). Tom Temprotran 06:05, 8 November 2006 (UTC)
Just where does the name "Duelist Region" come from? And TCG League, for that matter? -Happy Mask Man 18:37, 2 December 2006 (UTC)
Okay, this template doesn't need to be this big. People want to know this information about the regions? That's what the articles are for. Waiting for approval to knock down the size of this template several notches. --Pie 10:53, 4 December 2006 (UTC)
